Deciding between a fishing kayak and an inflatable pontoon can be a difficult one. They’re both portable, supremely versatile, and come without the hassle of full-size boats. But which one should you buy?
To help you make a definitive choice, we’ve listed some of the biggest differences between the two watercrafts. Fishing kayak vs. inflatable pontoon: which one is for you? Let’s find out!
What Is a Fishing Kayak?
Kayaks come in several types and purposes. Some are specifically designed for recreational purposes, while others are used for tours, surf play, and fishing.
Fishing kayaks, as you may have guessed, are targeted towards individuals who love to fish. Compared to most kayaks, fishing kayaks are wider to accommodate bulky fishing gear. They also use a sit-on-top design rather than a sit-inside design found in recreational kayaks.
Moreover, fishing kayaks are usually a little more agile than traditional kayaks as they don’t have as many features. They’re available in hard-shell and inflatable versions.
Pros
- Large storage area for fishing gear, tackle, and food
- Stable platform
- Fast maneuvers faster than inflatable pontoons
- Low maintenance
- More durable than inflatable pontoons
Cons
- Often more expensive than pontoons
- Sits lower in the water, making it more likely to tip over
What Is an Inflatable Pontoon?
Inflatable pontoons are basic watercrafts that float on two inflatable pontoons. Usually, these pontoons are supported by metal frames that act as a deck to support a passenger. They’re ideal for recreational purposes and, while generally heavier than fishing kayaks, easily maneuverable in open water or rivers.
Inflatable pontoons are available in a wide variety of shapes, sizes, and designs. Some of the most common types of inflatable pontoon include single-seater pontoons, two-man pontoons, and ultra-portable pontoons designed specifically for easy transportation and quick assembly.
Pros
- High seat decreases the chance of the pontoon tipping over
- One-man set up
- Cheaper than kayaks
- Multiple sizes and design options
- Can be rowed or motor-driven
Cons
- Often heavier and bulkier than kayaks
- Takes a while to set up and inflate
- Oars may get in the way of fishing
- Doesn’t usually come with a built-in storage
- Slower than kayaks, especially when met with waves and wind
Fishing Kayak vs. Inflatable Pontoon: What Are the Differences?
Now that we’ve discussed the advantages and disadvantages of fishing kayaks and inflatable pontoons, here are some of the biggest differences between the two:
Transportation
Fishing kayaks are typically made from fiberglass, graphite, or polyethylene. For this reason, hard-shell kayaks require boat trolleys or truck beds to be transported from one destination to another.
That said, inflatable fishing kayaks do exist. If you don’t mind spending several extra dollars in exchange for easy transport, you might want to buy an inflatable fishing kayak.
Inflatable pontoons are, well, inflatable! Before your trip, simply pack them into a duffel bag or in the bag of your trunk. You can carry them everywhere without any difficulties.
Set-Up
Inflatable pontoons are often difficult to set up. The bigger they are, the longer they take to inflate. On average, it takes about 10 to 15 minutes to fully set up an inflatable boat. On top of that, you’ll need to install the seats, motor, and other add-ons it came with.
Without the proper pump and equipment, it may take up to half an hour to fully set up an inflatable pontoon.
Fishing kayaks takes zero effort to set up. Simply pull them out of your truck bed and push them in the water. Of course, this can be quite the hassle if you’re going fishing alone. Fishing kayaks are often heavy, so you may need a hand or two to help you load and unload them from your car and into your fishing spot.
Durability
As you may have guessed, hard-shell fishing kayaks are way more durable than inflatable pontoons. Modern kayaks are usually made from rotomolded polyethylene or reinforced fiberglass. They’re designed to take almost any type of abuse environmental elements might throw at them. They’re not easily dented, scratched, or damaged.
This isn’t to say that inflatable pontoons are weak—quite the opposite, actually. They’re durable in their own right. Usually, they’re designed with abrasion-resistant PVC bottom and rugged nylons.
Also, despite being inflatable, it takes a bit of force to actually puncture the outer surface. They’re built for demanding in-water activities, after all. Regardless, they can’t be compared to the toughness of kayaks.
Maneuverability
In terms of maneuverability, both watercrafts have their own perks and drawbacks.
Fishing kayaks are long and slim, allowing you to fit into the narrowest of gaps. They also give you the freedom to fish in rocky locations without worrying about accidentally damaging them. Since they’re relatively lightweight, you can easily change direction by simply inclining your torso to the right or left.
Inflatable pontoons are heavier and bulkier than fishing kayaks, but they’re smooth and graceful on the water. Sure, they won’t bring you anywhere in record speed, not without a trolling motor at least, but they’re supremely stable and almost impossible to tip over.
Storage and Maintenance
Inflatable pontoons can be stored almost anywhere. Unlike fishing kayaks, you don’t have to have a specialized storage area for them. Most inflatable pontoons come with a storage bag, so that’s a plus.
In terms of maintenance, inflatable pontoons need to fully dry before storage. They need a full-body wash occasionally, too. Non-abrasive, environmentally friendly cleaners do the job perfectly.
Fishing kayaks need to be stored in a cool area, preferably away from direct sunlight. Unless your kayak is inflatable, it’ll take up a lot of space. Maintenance is similar to inflatable pontoons: wash with eco-friendly cleaners and fully dry before storing away.
Cost
Inflatable pontoons are usually more affordable than fishing kayaks. Entry-level models cost as low as $200, which makes them suitable for beginners and budget fishermen.
On the other hand, entry-level fishing kayaks cost almost ten times the price of inflatable pontoons—around $2,000. Fishing kayaks with extra fishing features may cost as much as $5,000.
If money isn’t a concern and storage isn’t a concern, consider getting yourself a fishing kayak. If you’re unsure about the hobby as a whole, start with an entry-level inflatable pontoon before graduating to more expensive options.
Final Thoughts
Fishing kayaks and inflatable pontoons come with their own pros and cons. If you’re a fisherman who values durability, time, and fishing versatility, fishing kayaks are for you. If you prefer convenience and storage over anything else, consider getting yourself an inflatable pontoon.