Angler kayaks combine two great pastime hobbies: fishing and kayaking.
It’s easy to get overwhelmed when choosing suitable kayaking gear. This is always the case with outdoor sports since there are just too many factors to consider.
We often hear people comparing the Pelican vs. Lifetime kayak. So, we decided to put the Pelican Sentinel 100X and the Lifetime Tamarack 120 in a head-to-head comparison.
Pelican vs. Lifetime Kayak: Overview
We tried to level the playing field here by choosing models of a similar range. They’re both sit-on-top angler kayaks with a maximum capacity of 275 pounds.
At first glance, they both look nearly identical. However, we found a lot of disparities in comfort, stability, and warranty guarantees.
Let’s take a deeper look:
Pelican Sentinel 100X Kayak
Pelican, a Quebec-based company, has been a major brand in the market since 1970. Their product range covers a lot of outdoor tools and accessories, including ABYC approved kayaks.
The Sentinel line comes in recreational and fishing models. Of course, we had to go with the angler/fishing kayak for this review.
The 100X model is a 9.5 foot, 44-pound kayak. It’s supposed to be for all skill levels, but we found it more suited for experienced users.
Pros:
- Lightweight
- An adjustable ERGO LOUNGE seating system
- Removable ExoPak storage compartment
- 1-year warranty
Cons:
- Standing onboard is tricky
Lifetime Tamarack 120 Kayak
Starting with basketball hoops, Lifetime was founded in Utah back in 1986. Today, the company brands its outdoor products as a sign of commitment and innovation.
The Tamarack is a 10 foot, 52-pound starter kayak for people interested in fishing. It covers the basic requirements expected at this price point.
However, this model has great potential for customization as your skill level increases. This way, you can add upgrades as you go.
Pros:
- Suitable for beginners
- Convenient and sturdy rod holders
- Multiple footrests
- 5-Year Limited Warranty
Cons:
- Uncomfortable seat
What Makes the Best Angler Kayak
Angler kayaks are usually wider and have at least one storage hatch. Rod holders are also crucial in any fishing kayak.
Both the Pelican and the Lifetime are wide enough. However, the right features and design can take away all the hassle out of your tranquil fishing trip.
Here’s your 101 guide to choosing your next fishing kayak:
Construction Material
The key to an ideal angler kayak is being light enough to make transportation easy. You should be able to carry it to and from your car without much effort.
Pelican Sentinel
Pelican makes kayaks from a high molecular weight polyethylene, and the Sentinel is no exception.
The Ram-x, a proprietary triple-layered material, helps keep the kayak sturdy and lightweight. Consequently, carrying the kayak is an easy one-man job.
Lifetime Tamarack
Although the Tamarack is made with UV-protected polyethylene, it’s still vulnerable to sun damage.
It’s not a terrible design flaw, but the kayak’s body can get a little soft with heat. We recommend storing it properly and steering clear for J-Hooks.
The Takeaway
Pelican is better constructed. Not just because of the material but thanks to the impressive ABYC approved design.
Comfort
Unlike recreational kayaks, anglers need to have maximum comfort. After all, fishing is a time-consuming hobby, and you need to sit inside for long periods.
Pelican Sentinel
We found the ERGO LOUNGE seating system better than the average kayak seat. You probably won’t have to replace it unless you have a back issue.
However, the Sentinel has a weird hook placement, and you could hurt your hands as you reach the paddles. The footrests aren’t as flexible as the Tamarack either.
Lifetime Tamarack
While the multiple footrests and the handgrips on the side are convenient, we found the seat uncomfortable.
Most likely, you’ll have to replace it with a cushioned stadium seat. It’s a simple DIY upgrade, though.
The Takeaway
For us, the Lifetime Tamarack comes on top in terms of comfort despite the seating system. It’s a simple issue to fix, and it makes all the difference.
Storage
Any angler kayak should have adequate storage space to keep in all your fishing tools. Cup and phone holders are a plus.
Pelican Sentinel
We do like that the ExoPak compartment is removable and quite spacious. It’s a nice opportunity to customize your kayaking experience.
Keep in mind that the hatch is not water-tight. If you have to leave any valuable or electronic devices, try putting them in ziplock bags first.
Lifetime Tamarack
You might find it hard to keep the storage compartment organized. Things slide around, and it could take a while to sort through the hatch.
You could install velcro mats on the bottom to keep things from sliding. You can also use some cardboard to make separators.
The Takeaway
Unless you’re willing to do some DIY upgrades, the Pelican Sentinel 100X wins this comparison point. The ExoPak is a more advanced hatch that makes storing your gear easier.
Stability
Because fishing requires a bit of swaying and pulling, the kayak should be as stable as possible. The frame should take some abuse without turning to the side.
Pelican Sentinel
The Sentinel has a multi-chine flat bottom hull that enhances the stability while casting and reeling.
With the twin-arched hull, we expected that standing inside would be easy. However, beginners might find it a bit tricky at first.
Lifetime Tamarack
Unlike the Sentinel, the Tamarack has a regular flat bottom. It’s efficient enough as a starter angler kayak.
You can add custom stabilizers for more balance. Keep in mind that some customizations can null the warranty claim.
The Takeaway
You can stand onboard the Sentinel if you have enough experience with fishing kayaks. You can take a well-behaved puppy on board too!
The Bottom Line
That’s a wrap on our Pelican vs. Lifetime Kayak comparison. Overall, Pelican is a go-to brand for experienced kayakers, while Lifetime is mostly a starter.
For an experienced kayaker, the Pelican Sentinel 100X is a clear winner.
Its lightweight Ram-x frame, removable ExoPak, and comfortable seating system are great features. However, the multi-chine hull just sealed the deal for us.
Don’t forget your scupper plugs and lifejacket at home. As always, stay safe and get ready to reel in some big fish!